M A S T E R   I N D E X

 

      STATE V. CHAPEL, 93-B-1818-6

 

JURY ORIENTATION                  VOLUME 1    8/04/95  Page     1

VOIR DIRE                         VOLUME 2    8/07/95  Page   256

                                  VOLUME 3    8/08/95  Page   564

                                  VOLUME 4    8/09/85  Page   876

                                  VOLUME 5    8/10/95  Page  1209

                                  VOLUME 6    8/11/95  Page  1440

                                  VOLUME 7    8/14/95  Page  1819

                                  VOLUME 8    8/15/95  Page  2176

                                  VOLUME 9    8/16/95  Page  2457

                                  VOLUME 10   8/17/95  Page  2699

JURY IMPANELED                    VOLUME 11   8/21/95  Page  2975

STATE'S EVIDENCE                  VOLUME 12   8/22/95  Page  3137

                                  VOLUME 13   8/23/95  Page  3421

                                  VOLUME 14   8/24/95  Page  3790

                                  VOLUME 15   8/25/96  Page  4211

                                  VOLUME 16   8/26/96  Page  4377

                                  VOLUME 17   8/28/96  Page  4540

                                  VOLUME 18   8/29/96  Page  4883

                                  VOLUME 19   8/30/96  Page  5196

Defendants_Evidence              VOLUME 20   8/31/96  Page  5436

                                  VOLUME 21   9/01/96  Page  5797

                                  VOLUME 22   9/02/96  Page  6051

REBUTTAL                          VOLUME 23   9/04/96  Page  6311

EVIDENCE TO JURY                  VOLUME 24   9/05/96  Page  6547

                                  VOLUME 24   9/06/95  Page  6750

                                  VOLUME 24   9/07/95  Page  6751

VERDICT - PRESENTENCE HEARING     VOLUME 25   9/08/95  Page  6769                                   

    VOLUME 25   9/09/95  Page  6869

VERDICT                           VOLUME 25   9/10/95  Page  7040

STATE'S EXHIBITS                  VOLUME 26      --    Page  7062

DEFENDANT'S EXHIBITS              VOLUME 27      --    Page  7388

                                  VOLUME 28      --    Page  7711

                                  VOLUME 29      --    Page  8034

                                  VOLUME 30      --    Page  8357

                                  VOLUME 31      --    Page  8680

                                  VOLUME 32      --    Page  9003

 

GENERAL INDEX     ii

EXAMINATION OF STATE'S WITNESSES    v

EXAMINATION OF DEFENDANT'S WITNESSES      xiv

STATE'S EXHIBITS  xix

DEFENDANT'S EXHIBITS    xxvi

 

 

      GENERAL INDEX

                                                            PAGE  STIPULATION, JOINING ISSUE    260

RULE OF SEQUESTRATION INVOKED 261

UNIFIED APPEAL    266

JURY PANEL A      297

JURY PANEL B      566

JURY PANEL C      755

JURY PANEL D      1000

JURY PANEL E      1210

JURY PANEL F      1441

JURY PANEL G      1640

JURY PANEL H      2006

JURY PANEL I      2277

JURY PANEL K      2472

JURY PANEL L      2638

JURY PANEL M      2796

UNIFIED APPEAL    2980

ISSUE JOINED      3064

JURY IMPANELED    3078

PRELIMINARY INSTRUCTIONS      3152,3155

OPENING STATEMENT - BY THE STATE    3161

OPENING STATEMENT - BY THE DEFENDANT      3176

EXAMINATION OF WITNESSES FOR THE STATE    3197

MOTION FOR MISTRIAL/COURT'S RULING  4556/4558

MOTION FOR MISTRIAL/COURT'S RULING  4856/4857

MOTION FOR MISTRIAL RENEWED/COURT'S RULING      5200/5201

THE STATE RESTS   5373,5402

CLOSED HEARING    5409

MOTIONS FOR DIRECTED VERDICT/COURT'S RULING     5430/5431

EXAMINATION OF WITNESSES FOR THE DEFENDANT      5442

CLOSED HEARING    6161

THE DEFENSE RESTS 6307

CLOSED HEARING    6315

REBUTTAL EVIDENCE 6323

THE STATE RESTS, REBUTTAL     6374

SURREBUTTAL ANNOUNCEMENT, THE DEFENDANT RESTS   6379

MOTION FOR DIRECTED VERDICT RENEWED/COURT'S RULING    6388/6389

UNIFIED APPEAL    6391

INQUIRY OF THE DEFENDANT      6400

VERDICT FORM      6401

CHARGE CONFERENCE 6402

CHARGE CONFERENCE RESUMED     6490

CHARGE CONFERENCE RESUMED     6538

OPENING ARGUMENTS BY THE STATE, MR. PORTER      6557

CLOSING ARGUMENTS BY THE DEFENDANT, MS. ROGAN   6572

CLOSING ARGUMENTS BY THE DEFENDANT, MR. MOORE   6609

     OBJECTION BY THE STATE   6627

CLOSING ARGUMENTS BY THE STATE, MR. PORTER      6637

     OBJECTION BY THE DEFENDANT     6658

     OBJECTION BY THE DEFENDANT     6666

CHARGE OF THE COURT     6669

EXCEPTIONS TO THE CHARGE      6723

UNIFIED APPEAL    6723

JURY QUESTION     6751,6760

VERDICT OF THE JURY     6770

JURY POLL   6772

PRESENTENCING HEARING - PRELIMINARY INSTRUCTIONS      6802

OPENING STATEMENTS - MR. PORTER     6803

OPENING STATEMENTS - MS. ROGAN      6805

EXAMINATION OF STATE'S WITNESSES    6808

EXAMINATION OF DEFENDANT'S WITNESSES     

CHARGE CONFERENCE 6976

UNIFIED APPEAL    6985,6991

CLOSING ARGUMENT - MR. PORTER 6995

CLOSING ARGUMENT - MS. ROGAN  7003

CHARGE OF THE COURT     7013

UNIFIED APPEAL    7028

JURY QUESTION     7031

RECHARGE OF THE COURT   7035

VERDICT OF THE JURY     7043

SENTENCING  7046

DISPOSITION OF EXHIBITS 7049

 

 

      EXAMINATION OF WITNESSES FOR THE STATE

8/22/95

 

THERON S. SMITH  Gwinnco Customper

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3197

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3207

 

JOE BYARS  Gwinnco Owner

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3216

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3225

 

ED BYERS GCPD, Police Officer, First Officer on Scene

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3229

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3233

 

JUDY GRAHAM  GCPD Crime Scene Technician

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 3238

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3256

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     3267

     Recross Examination - Ms. Rogan      3268

 

JAMES BRADLEY DEMPSEY  Medical Examiner Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 3273

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3279

 

BRIAN FRIST  Medical Examiner Blood Spatter Testimony on 8/29

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3293

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3318

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    3331

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      3336

     Further Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter  3338

     Further Recross Examination    none

 

EDWIN SCHMANSKI Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 3343

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3348

 

MARYANN JOHNSA  Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 3355

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3358

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Davis     3373

     Recross Examination - Ms. Rogan      3374

 

STACY JANET TURNER Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 3378

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3382

 

SEAN CHARLES  Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 3386

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3389

ROBERT BRUSIE Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 3396

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3403

 

8/23/95

    

ALLEN ROBERTSON  Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3433

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3441

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    3453

     Recross Examination      none

 

JOAN SHATTUCK Patient Relations Manager North Fulton Hospital

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3457

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3459

 

RAYMOND DANIEL GRAVITT  Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3462

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3466

 

WILLIAM HUTCHINS  Ear Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3472

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3477

 

SARA HUTCHINS  Ear Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3490

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3496

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    3502

     Recross Examination      none

 

PAUL OMODT  Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3503

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3514

 

KARL H. KAUTTER  Driver Eyewitness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3525

     Direct Resumed Examination - Mr. Porter    3563

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3564

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    3578

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      3579

 

DAVID WAYNE McGAHA, JR. Driver Witness

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3582

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3584

 

JUAN PERDOMO  Homeowner

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3588

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3591

 

 

JACK M. DUDLEY  Businessman, Friend and Sometime Employer of Michael Chapel

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 3598

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3605

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     3609

     Recross Examination      none

 

JOHN SCOTT SPEARMAN  Home Depot Employee and Part Time Bookkeeper and Tax Preparer for Michael Chapel

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 3616

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3622

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     3632

     Recross Examination - Ms. Rogan      3633

 

LEDORIS CHANDLER  Custodian of Records, South Trust Bank

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 3636

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3646

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     3649

     Recross Examination      none

 

LARRY R. HENDERSON  CEO, People’s Bank and Trust, Buford Georgia

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 3651

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3680

 

CYNTHIA LYNN EVANS  Teller, People’s Bank and Trust, Buford Georgia

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 3702

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3708

 

8/24/95

 

LENORA JAQUILLA TAYLOR  GCPD Communications Officer

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3802

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3804

 

LORETTA BATES     GCPD, 911 Dispatcher

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3806

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3811

 

MARILYN McDANIEL  GCPD, 911 Dispatcher

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3815

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3817

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    3825

     Recross Examination      none

 

MICHAEL KEITH THOMPSON  Adult Son of Emogene Thompson, Murder Victim

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3827

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  3839

     Cross Resumed Examination - Ms. Rogan      3855

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    3884

     Recross Examination - Ms. Rogan      3886

 

 

R. H. WINDERWEEDLE      GCPD, Police Sergeant, Day Watch Supervisor

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3891

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3893

     Redirecct Examination - Mr. Porter   3902

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      3904

 

DONALD E. STONE   GCPD, Police Sergeant, Chapel’ Direct Supervisor

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      3906

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  3919

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    3951

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      3956

 

MARSHA ARNOLD     Hearsay Witness, Friend of Victim

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 3998

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4004

 

VIRGINIA ANN CHANCE     Hearsay Witness, Friend of Victim

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 4014

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4017

 

DELORES HIRES BUREL     Hearsay Witness, Friend of Victim

     Direct Examination - Mr. Davis 4022

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4029

    

VALERIE HEATH     Manager, Sunshine Car Wash, Lawrenceville Georgia

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4060

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4069

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4081

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4084

     Further Examination - Mr. Smeal      4088

     Further Examination - Mr. Moore      4091

 

GREGORY M. SMITH  Director of Cash Services, Federl Reserve Bank of Atlanta

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4097

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4107

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4109

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4109

 

LAURIE B. PACE    Owner, Gwinnett Screen Graphics, Lawrenceville Georgia

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4111

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4117

 

MARK RUDOWSKI     GCPD, Police Officer, Arrested Kirsten Frazier-Forg at Eren’s Birthday Party, 4/18/93

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4123

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4128

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4137

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4138

 

 

 

CRAIG FOREST WILLIS     Sheriff’s Deputy, Booked Kiersten

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4142

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4145

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4147

     Recross Examination      none

 

8/25/95

 

KENDON E. CURTIS  Male Review Dance Manager, Part Time Tree Trimmer, Thief

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4224

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4232

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4244

     Recross Examination      none

 

C. E. BYERS GCPD, Police Officer, Previously Testified

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4254

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4257

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    4270

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4272

     Further Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter  4272

     Further Recross Examination - Mr. Moore    4273

 

RONALD L. DAVIS   GCPD, Police Captain, Investigated Murder

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4275

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4281

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    4306

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4311

 

JOSEPH ROBERT SORENSEN  County Employee, Wored on Tapes

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4337

     Cross Examination  none

 

8/26/95

 

JOHN LATTY  GCPD, Police Lieutenant, In Charge of Investigation

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4418

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4430

 

KATHY COLLIER MURRAY    Hospital Nurse, Drew Chapel’s Blood

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4512

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4516

 

KATHERINE WEST    GBI Crime Lab Evidence Technician

     Direct Examination -  Mr. Smeal      4518

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4520

 

JACKIE KINLAW     Manager, Quick Cash Pawn Shops

     Direct Examination -  Mr. Porter     4522

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4524

 

TAMMY HOBBS GCPD, Evidence Technician

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4526

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4528

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4530

     Recross Examination      none

 

8/28/95

 

EDDIE BALLEW GCDA, Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4564

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4567

 

MARY ANN WHITE, GCPD, Senior Crime Scene Technician

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4573

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4623

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4645

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4645

 

NANCY JENKINS     GCPD, Crime Scene Technician

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4647

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4656

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4670

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4670

 

T. B. HUNNICUTT   GCPD, Police Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4672

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4676

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4679

     Recross Examination      none

 

JAMES STEVEN CLINE      GCPD, Police Sergeant, Second to Latty

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4682

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4700

 

MIREYA MIDDLETON  GCPD, Senior Evidence Technician

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4732

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4737

 

P. T. SWANSON     GCPD, Evidence Technician

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4742

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4749

 

EMALINA SAKER,    GBI Crime Lab, Forensic Toxicologist

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4762

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4760

 

KEVIN CHARLES JENKINS   GBI Crime Lab, Forensic Microanalyst

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4762

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4764

 

JENNIFER S. WILSON      GBI Crime Lab, Forensic Serologist, DNA Analyst

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4796

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  4814

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4826

     Recross Examination - Ms. Rogan      4827

 

KELLY FITE  GBI Crime Lab, Firearms and Tool Mark Examiner

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 4833

          Direct [Jury Out] - Mr. Smeal   4847

          Cross [Jury out] - Mr. Moore    4850

          Redirect [Jury out] - Mr. Smeal 4852

     Direct Resumed - Mr. Smeal     4857

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4862

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     4873

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4876

 

8/29/95

WAYNE TAYLOR      GCPD, Police Investigator, Northside Precinct

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4887

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4890

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    4896

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4897

 

RAY DUNLAP  GCPD, Police Motorcycle Officer, (Amy’s Bulldog?)

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4900

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4903

    

B. J. TKACIK      GCPD, Criminal Investigator, Violent Crimes Youth Affairs Section

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4910

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4917

          Cross [Jury Out] - Mr. Moore    4921

          Redirect [Jury Out] - Mr. Porter      4925

     Cross Resumed - Mr. Moore      4936

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    4939

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4946

 

GLENN TEATINO     GCDA, Chief Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4947

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4950

 

RICHARD W. HINSON GCDA, Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4953

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4959

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    4963

     Recross Examination      none

 

ROBERT LEE GCPD, Police Sergeant, I/C Crime Scene Unit

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4966

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4969

 

BRIAN REDDY GCPD, Police Officer, On Chael’s Shift

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      4971

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  4979

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    4990

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      4991

 

HAROLD BENNETT    GCME, Medical Examiner Forensic Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      5005

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  5012

 

BRIAN FRIST GCME, Medical Examiner

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      5029

     Voir Dire Examination - Ms. Rogan    5030

     Direct Resumed - Mr. Porter    5034

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  5040

    

JACK BURNETTE     GCPD, Police Investigator, Case Chief Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      5064

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  5098

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    5125

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      5131

 

KEITH GOFF  GBI Crime Lab, Forensic Serologist and DNA Investigator

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 5135

 

8/30/95

   

KEITH GOFF  GBI Crime Lab, Forensic Serologist and DNA Investigator, Testified Yesterday

     Direct Resumed - Mr. Smeal     5202

     Direct Resumed - Mr. Smeal     5253

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  5256

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     5312

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      5314

 

GEORGE HERRIN, JR.      GBI Crime Lab, DNA Unit Supervisor, See Rebuttal Testimony 9/4

Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal      5319

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  5352

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     5368

     Recross Examination      none

 

HELEN BARRETT, Sister of victim, Emogene Thompson

     Direct Examination - by Mr. Davis    5372

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  5372

 

9/4/95 - REBUTTAL

 

MARY ANN WHITE    GCPD, Crime Scene Technician

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      6323

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  6325

 

SIDNEY S. KUSHNER

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 6327

     Voir Dire Examination - Mr. Moore    6331

     Voir Dire Examination - Mr. Smeal    6334

     Direct Resumed - Mr. Smeal     6334

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  6343

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     6348

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      6349

     Further Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal   6352

     Further Recross Examination    none

 

GEORGE HERRIN, JR.

     Direct Examination - Mr. Smeal 6354

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  6365

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal     6368

     Recross Examination - Mr. Moore      6370

     Further Redirect Examination - Mr. Smeal   6372

 

9/8/95 - PRESENTENCE HEARING

 

JOHN LATTY

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      6808

     Cross Examination - Ms. Rogan  6810

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Porter    6814

     Recross Examination - Ms. Rogan      6815

 

STEVE CLINE

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      6819

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  6823

 

B. J. TKACIK

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      6826

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  6827

 

KELLY FITE

     Direct Examination - Mr. Porter      6838

     Cross Examination - Mr. Moore  6845

 

 

 

      EXAMINATION OF WITNESSES FOR THE DEFENDANT

 

8/31/95

 

MARY ANN WHITE    GCPD, Crime Scene Technician, Previously Testified

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5442

          Direct Resumed [Jury Out] - Mr. Moore 5459

          Cross [Jury Out]  - Mr. Porter  5475

          Redirect [Jury Out] - Mr. Moore 5479

     Direct Resumed - Mr. Moore     5484

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5497

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore     5503

     Recross Examination      none

 

DONALD E. STONE   GCPD, Police Sergeant, Chapel’s Supervisor, Previously Testified

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5507

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5535

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore     5543

     Recross Examination - Mr. Porter     5544

     Further Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore   5545

     Further Recross Examination    none

 

ROBERT GARTH SLOAN      GCFD, Firefighter

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5548

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5561

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     5565

     Recross Examination      none

 

DAVID E. PIERCE, JR.    GCFD, Firefighter

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5568

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5576

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     5580

     Recross Examination - Mr. Porter     5582

     Further Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan   5583

     Further Recross Examination    none

 

STANLEY WILSON    GCFD, Firefighter

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5586

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5594

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     5601

     Recross Examination      none

 

JEFFREY TODD WESTBROOKS GCFD, Firefighter

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5603

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5609

 

ROBERT E. RAPIEN  Gwinnett County Sheriff Deputy, Previously testified

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5613

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5616

 

J. J. HOGAN       Gwinnett County Sheriff Deputy

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5620

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5623

 

DANA LYNN BLOUNT  Citizen, Friend of Michael Chapel

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5625

          Direct Resumed [Jury Out] - Ms. Rogan 5639

     Direct Resumed - Ms. Rogan     5643

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5644

 

VAN PARKER  Citizen, Wored at Chapel’s Gym

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5649

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5657

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     5660

     Recross Examination      none

 

PENNY MAUTERER    Private Investigator (Testron)

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5665

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5668

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     5669

     Recross Examination      none

 

TERRI DUNCAN      Paralegal, Photography Expert Witness, BA University of Alabama

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5671

          Direct Resumed [Jury Out] - Mr. Moore 5676

          Cross [Jury Out] - Mr. Porter   5681

 

BILL CARTY  GCPD, Police Sergeant, Narcotics

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5703

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5707

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore     5708

     Recross Examination      none

 

M. D. POWELL      GCPD, Police Lieutenant, Built and Maintained Chapel Database

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5710

     Cross [Jury Out] - Mr. Porter  5743,5757

     Redirect [Jury Out] - Ms. Rogan      5749,5759,5767

 

9/1/95

 

MICHAEL D. POWELL GCPD, Police Lieutenant, Testimony Continued

     Direct Resumed Examination - Ms. Rogan     5829

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5862

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     5870

     Recross Examination - Mr. Porter     5875

 

RUTH CRONIC Citizen, Involved in Accidnet

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5890

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5893

 

HORACE F. MADDOX  Citizen, Witness to Cronic Accident

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5895

     Cross Examination none

 

CASSANDRA RICE    Citizen, Worked at Chapel Gym

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5900

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5907

 

MONICA HACK       GCPD, Internal Affairs, Once Worked Street With Chapel

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5909

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5911

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore     5912

     Recross Examination      none

 

NANETTE CROSS     Bookkeeper, AVP, People’s Bank and Trust, Buford Georgia

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5914

     Cross Examination -      none

 

GREG CHAPEL       GC Sheriff’s Deputy, Brother to Michael Chapel

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 5920

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5924

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore     5925

 

WALTER M. BRITT   GC Attorney, Chapel’s First Attprmeu

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5933

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 5939

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     5942

     Recross Examination      none

 

IAN RATNER CPA, Accounting Litigation Specialist

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 5950

     Cross Examination - Mr. Smeal  5986

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     6001

     Recross Examination - Mr. Smeal      6005

 

DARRYL THOMPSON   Citizen, Friend of Chapel, Installed Red Light in Chapel’s Police Unit

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6008

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 6013

 

JUNG CHOI   DNA Expert Witness, Associate Professor Genetics and Molecular Biology Georgia Tech, BS Biology MIT, PhD UCSD

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 6020

     Voir Dire Examination - Mr. Smeal    6022

     Direct Resumed Examination - Mr. Moore     6029

 

9/2/95

 

JUNG CHOI   DNA Expert Witness, Associate Professor Genetics and Molecular Biology Georgia Tech, BS Biology MIT, PhD UCSD (Coneinued)

     Cross Examination - Mr. Smeal  6053

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore     6086

     Recross Examination - Mr. Smeal      6091

     Further Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore   6094

     Further Recross Examination - Mr. Smeal    6095

 

MARTIN SHAPIRO Expert Witness, Professor of Psychology (Statistical Measurements) Emory University

     Direct Examination - Mr. Moore 6099

     Voir Dire Examination - Mr. Smeal    6102

     Direct Resumed - Mr. Moore     6114

     Cross Examination - Mr. Smeal  6127

     Redirect Examination - Mr. Moore     6152

     Recross Examination - Mr. Smeal      6153

 

MICHAEL H. CHAPEL Defendant

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6188

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 6268

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     6291

     Recross Examination - Mr. Porter     6299

 

9/9/95 - PRESENTENCE HEARING

 

SHELLY WISNER

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6879

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 6881

 

LINDA LUTZ

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6882

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 6885

 

JANE MORGAN TABOR

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6886

     Cross Examination  none

 

RANDALL CRAIG ELLINGTON

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6889

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 6893

 

MARK DORMINY

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6896

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 6900

 

FRITZ MUSSER

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6902

     Cross Examination none

 

CHARLES GREGORY CHAPEL

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6908

     Cross Examination  none

 

JOHN ALLEN CHAPEL

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6912

     Cross Examination  none

 HAROLD L. CHAPEL

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6915

     Cross Examination  none

 

ROBERT DANIEL SHAFFER

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6923

     Cross Examination - Mr. Porter 6935

     Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan     6943

     Recross Examination - Mr. Porter     6950

     Further Redirect Examination - Ms. Rogan   6954

     Further Recross Examination    none

 

DOROTHY MARILYN CHAPEL

     Direct Examination - Ms. Rogan 6956

     Cross Examination  none

 

 

 

      INDEX TO EXHIBITS FOR THE STATE

 

                                                         ADMITTED

S-1     Calendar, April 1993  3146

S-2     Diagram, Gwinnco Muffler Shop     3146

S-3     Diagram, Peachtree Industrial Boulevard 3146

S-4     Aerial Photograph Northern Gwinnett County    3146

S-5     Photograph, Lincoln Continental   3204

S-6     Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3204

S-7     Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3204

S-8     Photograph, Gwinnco Muffler 3223

S-9     Photograph, Gwinnco Muffler 3223

S-10    Photograph, Gwinnco Muffler 3223

S-11    Photograph, Lincoln Continental   3223

S-12    Photograph, Lincoln and Victim    3233

S-13    Photograph, Lincoln, Flat Tire    3233

S-14    Photograph, Lincoln at Scene      3247

S-15    Photograph, Victim in Vehicle     3247

S-16    Photograph, Victim in Vehicle     3247

S-17    Photograph, Vehicle, Inside Driver's Side Door      3247

S-18    Photograph, Vehicle, Driver's Side Door 3247

S-19    Photograph, Vehicle, Rear Floorboard    3247

S-20    Photograph, Vehicle, Front Passenger Side     3247

S-21    Photograph, Projectile      3247

S-22    Photograph, Vehicle Interior      3247

S-23    Victim's Glasses      3252

S-24    Tire from Vehicle     5380

S-25    Test Tube Containing Blood  5152

S-25A   Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3306

S-26    Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3306

S-27    Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3306

S-28    Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3306

S-29    Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3306

S-30    Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3306

S-31    Photograph, Emogene Thompson      3306

S-32    Photographic Lineup   5381

S-33    Life Tech Equipment Check, $1,500 3604

S-34    11/92 Checking Account Statement, E. Thompson 3654

S-35A   11/92 Deposit Slip, Emogene Thompson Account  3656

S-35B   Check and Bank Cash-out Document, E. Thompson Acct  3656

S-36    3/93 Savings Account Statement, Emogene Thompson    3657

S-37    1/93 Savings Deposit Slip, Emogene Thompson   3658

S-38A   1/93 Check 526, Emogene Thompson Account      3659

S-38B   1/93 Check 525, Emogene Thompson Account      3659

S-38C   1/93 Check 522, Emogene Thompson Account      3659

S-38D   1/93 Check 520, Emogene Thompson Account      3659

S-39    3/93 Withdrawal from Savings, E. Thompson Account   3660

S-40    Bank Teller Calculating Machine Tape    3661

S-41    3/93 Checking Account Statement, Emogene Thompson   3662

S-42A   3/93 Deposit Slip, Emogene Thompson Account   3663

S-42B   3/93 Bank Cash-out Slip, E. Thompson Account  3663

S-42C   Citizens Bank Check   3663

S-42D   CIBA Pay Check  3663

S-42E   Veterans Life Insurance Company Check   3663

S-43    1/93 Chapel Iron World the Gym Bank Account   3664

S-44    2/93 Chapel Iron World the Gym Bank Account   3665

S-45    3/93 Chapel Iron World the Gym Bank Account   3666

S-46    4/93 Chapel Iron World the Gym Bank Account   3668

S-47    4/7/93 Deposit Slip, Iron World the Gym Account     3669

S-48    4/16/93 Deposit Slip, Iron World the Gym Account    3670

S-49    4/19/93 Deposit Slip, Iron World the Gym Account    3670

S-50    4/19/93 Deposit Slip, Iron World the Gym Account    3671

S-51    4/29/93 Deposit Slip, Iron World the Gym Account    3672

S-52    3/24/93 Check 305 to Southern Bell      3673

S-53    4/5/93 Check 306 to Atlanta Journal-Constitution    3673

S-54    4/9/93 Check 307 to Mike Brownlee       3673

S-55    4/10/93 Check to Scott Spearman   3674

S-56    4/12/93 Check 309 to City of Lawrenceville    3675

S-57    Check 310 for Cash    3675

S-58    4/15/93 Check to Dixie Labs 3676

S-59    4/15/93 Check 312 to the Gordon Burrell Estate      3676

S-60    4/21/93 Check 313 to John Chapel  3676

S-61    4/21/93 Check 314 to Cash   3677

S-62    4/22/93 Check 315 to City of Buford     3677

S-63A   3/11/93 General Ledger Credit     3678

S-63B   3/11/93 Bank Cash-in Slip of Exhibit S-63a    3679

S-64    3/11/93 General Ledger Credit     3679

S-65    1/93 Bank Statement, Michael and Eren Chapel  3645

S-66    2/93 Bank Statement, Michael and Eren Chapel  3645

S-67    3/93 Bank Statement, Michael and Eren Chapel  3645

S-68    4/93 Bank Statement, Michael and Eren Chapel  3645

S-69A   Paycheck  3645

S-69B   4/12/93 Deposit Slip, Chapel Account    3645

S-70A   Check to Chapel 3645

S-70B   Bank Cash-out Document      3645

S-70C   4/27/93 Deposit Slip, Chapel Account    3645

S-71A   Check to Eren Chapel  3645

S-71B   Check to Eren Chapel  3645

S-71C   Bank Cash-in Document 3645

S-71D   4/22/93 Deposit Slip, Chapel Account    3645

S-72    Audiocassette Copy of 911 Call    3808

S-73    Call Card, 911  3809

S-74    Winderweedle Note to Mike Chapel  4598

S-75    Gwinnett County Police Unit 197, Rear View    5081

S-76    Gwinnett County Police Unit 197, Front View   5081

S-77    4/3/93 Log Sheet, Michael Chapel  5385

S-78    Photo, Emogene Thompson     4028

S-79    Car Wash Receipt      4092

S-80    Gwinnett Screen Graphics Order Form     4122

S-81    Federal Reserve Board of Governors Printout   4099

S-82    Federal Reserve Currency Requisition Report   4106

S-83    Gwinnett Citation to Kiersten Frazier-forg    4150

S-84    Gwinnett Cash Bond Document for Frazier-forg  4150

S-85    Gwinnett Citation to Kiersten Frazier-forg    4150

S-86    Gwinnett Cash Bond Document for Frazier-forg  4150

S-87    Photo, Eren Chapel    Record Only  5061

S-87S   Substituted Photo of S-87, Eren Chapel  5063

S-88    Original Videotape 1, 4/93 4280

S-89    Original Videotape 2, 4/93  4280

S-90    Original Videotape 3, 4/93  4280

S-91    Copy of Videotape 1, S-88   Record Only  4340

S-92    Copy of Videotape 2, S-89   Record Only  4340

S-93    Copy of Videotape 3, S-90   Record Only  4340

S-94    Redacted Transcript of Statement  Record Only  4331

S-95    Original Page 38, Statement Record Only  4358

S-96    Original Pages 124, 125, 126, Statement       Record Only  5387

S-97    Briefcase 5388

S-98    Gwinnett County Evidence Bag      4430

S-99    Police Issue Leather Gear   4430

S-100   Blood Vials and Evidence Bag, Mike Chapel     5151

S-101   Quick Cash Pawn Shop Agreement    4524

S-102   Crime Scene Video     4579

S-103   Paper Bag Withdrawn  5389

S-104   Paper Bag 4837

S-105   Plastic Evidence Bag  4837

S-106   Canister Containing Projectile    4837

S-107   Brown Paper Bag Withdrawn  5390

S-108   Brown Paper Bag 4837

S-109   Brown Paper Bag with Writing      4837

S-110   Canister Containing Projectile    4837

S-111   Photo, Luminol Area on Car Seat   4603

S-112   Photo, Front Seat of Unit 197     5391

S-113   Photo, Front Passenger Seat 5391

S-114   Photo, Front Passenger Seat 5391

S-115   Photo, Armrest  5391

S-116   Passenger Seat and Armrest from Unit 197      4804

S-117   White Bag Covering Car Seat Not Offered

S-118   White Bag Covering Car Seat Not Offered

S-119   Armrest   4804

S-120   Bag Covering Arm Rest, S-119      5392

S-121A  Hundred Dollar Bill   5393

S-121B  Hundred Dollar Bill   5393

S-121C  Hundred Dollar Bill   5393

S-121D  Hundred Dollar Bill   5393

S-122   Photo, Locker 34      5393

S-123   Clipboard with Log Sheets and Yellow Legal Pad      5394

S-124   Black Metal Flashlight      5394

S-125   Blue Police Campaign Hat    5394

S-126   Yellow Rain Pants     5394

S-127   Evidence Bag    5395

S-128   Bag in Which Rain Jacket Was Placed     4812

S-129   Rain Jacket     4812

S-130   Car Seat Swatch Removed for Testing     5153

S-131   Handgun, RG .38 Caliber     5395

S-132   Evidence Bag Containing Rain Cap  4965

S-133   Clear Plastic Rain Cap      4965

S-134   Photo, Briefcase Contents   4965

S-135   Yellow Notepad from Briefcase     5396

S-136   Photo, Investigator Burnette Holding Notepad  4965

S-137   Brian Reddy Daily Log Sheet 5199

S-138   Piece of Paper Showing Victim's Phone Number  5130

S-139   Original Autorad, MS-1 Probe      5184

S-140   Original Autorad, YNH-24 Probe    5184

S-141   Original Autorad, TBQ-7 Probe     5184

S-142   Original Autorad, PH-30 Probe     5184

S-143   Original Autorad, V-1 Probe 5184

S-144   Original Autorad, LH-1 Probe      5184

S-145   Original Autorad, Partial Digestion, MS-1 Probe     5223

S-146   Original Autorad, Partial Digestion, YNH-24 Probe   5223

S-147   Original Autorad, Partial Digestion, TBQ-7 Probe    5223

S-148   Original Autorad, Partial Digestion, V-1 Probe      5223

S-149   Original Autorad, Partial Digestion, LH-1 Probe     5223

S-150   Original Autorad, Replicate Sample, TBQ-7 Probe     5223

S-151   Original Autorad, Replicate Sample, PH-30 Probe     5223

S-139A  X-ray Copy, MS-1 Probe      5183

S-140A  X-ray Copy, YNH-24 Probe    5183

S-141A  X-ray Copy, TBQ-7 Probe     5183

S-142A  X-ray Copy, PH-30 Probe     5183

S-143A  X-ray Copy, V-1 Probe 5183

S-144A  X-ray Copy, LH-1 Probe      5183

S-145A  X-ray Copy, Partial Digestion, MS-1 Probe     5255

S-146A  X-ray Copy, Partial Digestion, YNH-24 Probe   5255

S-147A  X-ray Copy, Partial Digestion, TBQ-7 Probe    5255

S-148A  X-ray Copy, Partial Digestion, V-1 Probe      5255

S-149A  X-ray Copy, Partial Digestion, LH-1 Probe     5255

S-150A  X-ray Copy, Replicate Sample, TBQ-7 Probe     5255

S-151A  X-ray Copy, Replicate Sample, PH-30 Probe     5255

S-139B  Photo Enlargement, Autorad MS-1 Probe   5183

S-140B  Photo Enlargement, Autorad YNH-24 Probe 5183

S-141B  Photo Enlargement, Autorad TBQ-7 Probe  5183

S-142B  Photo Enlargement, Autorad PH-30 Probe  5183

S-143B  Photo Enlargement, Autorad V-1 Probe    5183

S-144B  Photo Enlargement, Autorad LH-1 Probe   5183

S-145B  Photo Enlargement, Partial Digestion, MS-1 Probe    5223

S-146B  Photo Enlargement, Partial Digestion, YNH-24 Probe  5223

S-147B  Photo Enlargement, Partial Digestion, TBQ-7 Probe   5223

S-148B  Photo Enlargement, Partial Digestion, V-1 Probe     5223

S-149B  Photo Enlargement, Partial Digestion, LH-1 Probe    5223

S-150B  Photo Enlargement, Replicate Sample, TBQ-7 Probe    5223

S-151B  Photo Enlargement, Replicate Sample, PH-30 Probe    5223

S-152   Probe Chart     Record Only  5398

S-153   Sizing Sheet for Probe LH-1 6458

S-154   Newspaper TV Guide for April 11-17      5579

S-155   DNA Article     Not Offered

S-156   Shapiro Database      Not Offered

S-157   Shapiro Printout Showing Duplications   Not Offered

S-158   Article   Not Offered

S-159   David Dower Response to Shapiro Theories      Not Offered

S-160   Copy of Check   Not Offered

S-161   Copy of Check   Not Offered

S-162   Photo - White and Patrol Car      6324

S-163   Procedure for Partial Digestion   Not Offered

S-164   Herrin Article  Not Offered

S-165   Herrin Article 1993   Not Offered

S-166   Camouflage Rifle Case 6825

S-167   M-16 Rifle      6825

S-168   Ammunition - 7 Magazines    6825

S-169   Rifle Suppressor, Silencer  6825

S-170   Bipod for M-16  6825

S-171   Brown Box, Bag, Pipes, Wire 6842

S-172   Psychological Evaluation 3/1/84   Record Only  6940,6987

 

 

      INDEX TO EXHIBITS FOR THE DEFENDANT

                                                         ADMITTED

D-1    Newspaper Article      Record Only

D-2    Composite, Photographs of Police Cars    3350

D-3    Scale Drawing of Area at Gwinnco Muffler 3352

D-4    Johnsa Statement Record Only

D-5    Johnsa Overlay   3377

D-6    Turner Overlay   3384

D-7    Charles Overlay  3392

D-8    Brusie Overlay   3408

D-9    Robertson Statements   Record Only  3455

D-10   Robertson Overlay      3452

D-11   Gravitt Statement      Record Only  3471

D-12   William Hutchins Statement   Record Only  3482

D-13   Sara Hutchins Statement      Record Only

D-14   Photo, Buford Police Officer 3933

D-15   Photo, Officer Staunton      3933

D-16   Photo, Officer Evans   3933

D-17   Photo, Officer Stone   3933

D-18   Photo, Lieutenant Knight     3933

D-19   Photo, Officer Martin  3933

D-20   Photo, Sergeant Shell  3933

D-21   Photo, Officer Awtry   3933

D-22   Photo, Officer Pusbach 3933

D-23   Photo, Officer Zimmerman     3933

D-24   Photo, Officer Yonker  3933

D-25   Photo, Officer Drake   3933

D-26   Photo, Officer REDDY   3933

D-27   Photo, Lieutenant Morgan     3933

D-28   Photo, Sergeant Edmunds      3933

D-29   Photo, Officer Geidner 3933

D-30   Photo, Officer Danny Burke   3933

D-31   Photo, Officer J. P. Morgan  3933

D-32   Photo, Sergeant Winderweedle 3933

D-33   Photo, Officer Rosa    3933

D-34   Photo, Corporal Byers  3933

D-35   Photo, Corporal Wilhoit      3933

D-36   Photo, Lieutenant Greenwood  3933

D-37   Photo, Officer Jack Garner   3933

D-38   Photo, Corporal Stratameyer  3933

D-39   Photo, Sergeant Tyson  3933

D-40   Photo, Officer Bridgefarmer  3933

D-41   Photo, Officer Mornings      3933

D-42   Photo, Sergeant Tim Hunter   3933

D-43   Photo, Officer Hughy   3933

D-44   Photo, Officer Yeager  3933

D-45   Mcgaha Overlay   3586

D-46   Michael Thompson Deposition  Record Only  6462

D-47   D. E. Stone Statement  Record Only  6462

D-48   Gwinnett County Police Precinct Map      6462

D-49   Michael Thompson Statement to Police     Record Only  6463

D-50   Marsha Arnold Statement to Police  Record Only  6463

D-51   Transcript of Delores Burel Interview    Record Only  6463

D-52   Transcript of Delores Burel Interview    Record Only  6463

D-53   Valerie Heath Statement to Police  Record Only  4089

D-54   Rudowski Incident Report     Record Only  6464

D-55   Photo, Gas Pump Area, Northside Precinct 4269

D-56   Photo, Interview Room  4436

D-57   Photo, Door to Interview Room      4436

D-58   Photo, Interior of Interview Room  4436

D-59   Photo, Sugar Hill City Marshal     Withdrawn  6473

D-60   Brian Reddy Log Sheet  Record Only  5199

D-61   Map of City of Buford  4465

D-62   Crime Lab Report 6466

D-63   Note Handwritten by Jack Burnette  Record Only  4507,6466

D-64   Blueprint of Gwinnett County Police Department 4659

D-65   Aerial Photo, Gwinnett County Police Department      4663

D-66   Photo, Door from Hangar to Shop Area     4659

D-67   Photo, Shop Garage Door      4659

D-68   Photo, Interior of Ambulance Hangar      4659

D-69   Photo, Unit 197 Parked in Garage   4665

D-70   Statement from Brian Reddy   Record Only  4709

D-71   Incomplete Police Incident Report  5126

D-72   Incomplete Police Incident Report  5444

D-73   Incompleted Police Report    5444,6225

D-74   Photo, Iron World the Gym    4730

D-75   Testron Diatary Supplements  6468

D-76   Key Ring with Keys and Whistle     6469

D-77   Property Sheet, Case 93-012445     Record Only  6469

D-78   Accident Report, 4/6/93      Record Only  5899,6470

D-79   Crime Lab Report, August 24, 1995  Record Only  4786,6471

D-80   Crime Lab Report, June 22, 1995    Record Only  6471

D-81   Crime Lab Report, January 11, 1995 Record Only  6471

D-82   Brian Reddy Log Sheet, April 3     6471

D-83   Brian Reddy Log Sheet, April 12    6471

D-84   Photo, Morgue Table    5016

D-86   Photo, Trash Can in Morgue   5016

D-87   Photo, Autopsy Sink and Area 5016

D-88   Photo, Morgue Table    5016

D-89   Photo, Autopsy Room Sign     Withdrawn

D-90   Photo, Sugar Hill City Marshal     5108

D-91   Log Sheet, Deputy Sheriff Rapien   6474

D-92   Pack of Cigarettes     5113

D-93   Cigarette Case   5113

D-94   Photo, Two Incident Reports, D-72 and D-73     6475

D-95   Photo, Shirt with Blood Stains     5315

D-96   Book, DNA Technology in Forensic Science Record Only  5315

D-97   Telephone Message by Jennifer Wilson     Record Only  6476

D-98   Affidavit Certifying Exhibit D-99  Record Only  5441

D-99   U. S. Department of Justice Booklet      Record Only  5441

 

D-101  Plastic Bag, Miscellaneous Papers  Record Only  5497

D-102  Pursuit Pack     5447

D-103  Plastic Figurine 5449

D-104  Shoulder Holster 5450

D-105  Living Bible     Record Only  5486

D-106  Leather Gloves   5486

D-107  Plastic Box from Trunk 5485

D-108  Metal Clipboard  5493

D-109  Metal Ticket Book Holder     5487

D-110  $6.31 Removed from Patrol Car      5487

D-111  Book of Raffle Tickets 5488

D-112  TV Set     5488

D-113  Glasses Case     5489

D-114  Box of Cigars    5490

D-115  Cup Holder 5490

D-116  Right-hand Glove 5491

D-117  Right-hand Glove 5493

D-118  Coffee Mug 5493

D-119  Sunglasses 5493

D-120  Sunglasses 5493

D-121  Clipboard  5493

D-122  Crown Royal Bag  5493

D-123  Plastic Bag Containing Various Items     5493

D-124  Envelope Containing Light Bulb     5493

D-125  Hand Mirror      5493

D-126  Package of Soup  5493

D-127  Package of Gum   5493

D-128  Package of Gum   5493

D-129  Brown Manila Envelopes 5493

D-130  Evidence Tag     5493

D-131  Photo      6200

D-132  Photo      6200

D-133  Photo      6200

D-134  Photo      6200

D-135  Photo, Inside Patrol Vehicle Trunk 5505

D-136  Photo, Pursuit Pack    5505

D-137  Certified Copy of TV Listing and Weather Data  5519

D-138  Printout, D. E. Stone Call 4/15    Record Only  6483

D-139  Photo, Fire Station 14 Day Room    5554

D-140  Photo, Fire Station 14 Day Room    5554

D-141  Photo, Fire Station 14 Day Room    5554

D-142  Statement from Firefighter Sloan   Record Only  5560

D-143  Statement from Firefighter Pierce  Record Only  5582

D-144  Statement from Fire Engineer Wilson      Record Only  5593

D-145  Statement from Firefighter Westbrooks    Record Only  5609

D-146  Bottle of Testron      5667

D-147  Receipt for Testron Purchase 5667

D-148  Mdt Records      Record Only  5834

D-149  Telephone Records      Record Only  5837

D-150  Database Summary Record Only  5839

D-151  Notebook Containing Mdt Entries    Record Only  5840

D-152  Photo, Cronic Vehicle  5893

D-153  Photo, Cronic Vehicle  5893

D-154  Bank Records, Iron World the Gym   5916

D-155  Bank Records, Michael and Eren Chapel    5929

D-156  Business Licenses 1990 - 1993      5929

D-157  Copies of Checks to Walt Britt     5937

D-158  Chart, Gym/Personal Banking Accounts     Record Only  5974

D-159  Chart, Gym Bank Account 1991-1993  Record Only  5957

D-160  Chart, Gym Bank Account 1/93-4/93  Record Only  5960

D-161  Chart, Chapel Account 1991-1993    Record Only  5969

D-162  Chart, Account 1/93-4/93     Record Only  5973

D-163  Chart, Gym Account Summary   Record Only  5976

D-164  Chart, Chapel Account Summary      Record Only  5979

D-165  Chart, Gym/Personal Account Summary      Record Only  5981

D-166  Photo, New County Police Car 6196

D-167  Photo, Older Model County Police Car     6196

D-168  Gym Sign-in Sheet      6215

D-169  Gym Sign-in Sheet      6215

D-170  Photo, Victim's Trailer      6222

D-171  Chapel Log Sheet 4/93  6232

D-172  Log Sheet with Dispatch to Arden Drive   6248

D-173  Mdt Log Sheet    Record Only  6469

D-175  News Article, Rodney King Case     6871

D-176  Transcript from ABAC, Certified Copy     6871

D-177  Marine Corps Records   6872

D-178  Dekalb County Personnel Record     6872

D-179  1986 Gwinnett County Performance Appraisal     6872

D-180  1987 Gwinnett County Performance Appraisal     6872

D-181  1988 Gwinnett County Performance Appraisal     6872

D-182  1989 Gwinnett County Performance Appraisal     6872

D-183  1990 Gwinnett County Performance Appraisal     6872

D-184  1992 Gwinnett County Performance Appraisal     6872

D-185  1993 Gwinnett County Performance Appraisal     6872

D-186  Letter of Commendation from D. Kidwell, 3/5/86 6873

D-187  Page Two of D-186      6873

D-188  Page Three of D-186    6873

D-189  Letter of Appreciation from Chief of Police    6873

D-190  Letter of Appreciation, Asst. Chief of Police, 4/86 6873

D-191  Letter of Commendation, 4/4/86     6874

D-192  Letter of Appreciation, Asst. Chief of Police 12/86  6874

D-193  Letter of Commendation, 1/14/87    6874

D-194  Letter of Commendation, 1/30/87    6874

D-195  Letter of Commendation, 7/22/88    6874

D-196  Letter of Commendation, 5/1/89     6875

D-197  Letter of Commendation, 5/9/89     6875

D-198  Letter of Commendation, 6/20/89    6875

D-199  Service Award, 9/27/89 6875

D-200  Letter of Commendation, 1/19/90    6875

D-201  Letter of Commendation, 1/24/90    6876

D-202  Letter of Commendation, 2/19/90    6876

D-203  Letter of Commendation, 6/20/90    6876

D-204  Letter of Thanks, 8/2/90     6876

D-205  Letter of Commendation, 2/15/91    6876

D-206  Letter of Commendation, 3/18/91    6877

D-207  Letter of Commendation, 3/22/91    6877

D-208  Letter of Appreciation 3/27/91     6877

D-209  Letter of Commendation, 10/23/91   6877

D-210  Letter of Commendation, 2/17/92    6877

D-211  Letter of Commendation, 4/20/92    6878

D-212  Letter of Commendation, 5/18/92    6878

D-213  Letter of Commendation, 12/16/92   6878

D-214  Psychological Report, 1984   Record Only  6944

D-215  Marine Photo     6961

D-216  Photo, Chapel at Nursery     6962

D-217  Photo, Chapel with Daughter  6962

D-218  Photo, Son Chad  6965

D-219  Photo, Daughter Chelsea      6965

 

 

i